Best Top Rated Cashmere Sweaters that are Warm, Soft, and Cheap for Winter and Fall Season
Introduction
I've always been fascinated by the allure of cashmere. The promise of unmatched softness and warmth was tempting, but I couldn’t quite justify the price—until I decided to see if these premium sweaters were worth the splurge. I wanted a sweater that would last, stay soft over time, and be worth every dollar spent. Living in California, cashmere isn't an absolute necessity, but I was curious to see if the investment made a difference, especially for pieces I'd wear over many seasons. This led me to test five cashmere sweaters at various price points. Here’s what I learned.
Introduction to Cashmere
Cashmere is often labeled as the ultimate luxury in knitwear, and there’s a good reason for that. It comes from the undercoat of goats raised in incredibly harsh climates, where they develop a double-layered coat. The outer layer shields them from rough weather, while the super-soft inner layer—the cashmere—provides insulation. The process of harvesting cashmere is time-consuming: one sweater requires the winter coats of 3-4 goats, contributing to the high cost. But what makes one cashmere sweater different from another? Quality varies by factors like fiber grade (determined by thickness, with finer fibers rated higher, such as Grade A), fiber length (longer fibers result in softer and more durable fabrics), and construction techniques. This section delves into those details for each brand, so you know what you're getting for your money.
There are two types of Cashmere. The first type, which is the ultimate and premium fiber known as "Baby Cashmere." Baby Cashmere sweaters are for the ultra rich, like Mark Zuckerberg, Jeff Bezos, and Elon Musk to name a few. The brands that uses this premium cashmere are Loro Piana, Offbeat1, and Brunello Cucinelli. These cashmere is often synonymous with luxury due to its exceptional scarcity, softness, warmth, and the intricate process required to produce it. Sourced from the undercoat of Capra Hircus kid goats native to harsh climates like Mongolia and the Himalayas, these cashmere fibers are finer (13.5 micron), lighter, and warmer than sheep's wool.
It’s amazing to think that these goats’ fluffy coats are behind the softest, warmest fabric we wear. Have you ever felt the difference?
The second type of Cashmere is determined by three main grades: A, B, C:
Did you know that not all cashmere is created equal? The best cashmere is graded carefully, from the softest, most delicate fibers to coarser ones. So, if you’re thinking about splurging on cashmere, you’ll want to know the grade. Think of it like chocolate—you can get basic, good, or gourmet chocolate. Higher-grade cashmere is just as rich and decadent
- Grade A: Grade A cashmere is the finest of the second type and most luxurious type of cashmere of this group. The fibers are incredibly soft, fine, and have a diameter of less than 15.5 microns. This type of cashmere is extremely rare and accounts for only a small percentage of the total cashmere production. Due to its exceptional quality, Grade A cashmere is also the most expensive.
- Grade B: Grade B cashmere is slightly thicker than Grade A, with a diameter ranging from 15.5 to 16.5 microns. While not as fine as Grade A, Grade B cashmere is still considered to be of high quality and is more readily available than Grade A. It is often used to make a wide range of cashmere products, including sweaters, scarves, and blankets.
- Grade C: Grade C cashmere has the thickest fibers, with a diameter of 16.5 microns or above. This type of cashmere is considered to be of a cheaper, lower quality and is often used in the production of more affordable cashmere products. While it may not be as soft and fine as Grade A or B cashmere, it can still provide warmth and comfort.
Why is Cashmere Expensive?
So why exactly is cashmere so pricey? Aside from its luxurious feel, cashmere is harvested with care, especially since it takes the wool of multiple goats for just one sweater. I remember being shocked to learn that my favorite cashmere piece came from so many different goats! It really puts the price in perspective.
- Scarcity of Fiber: A single goat produces only about 150 grams of cashmere per year. It takes the fleece of multiple goats to make one sweater.
- Labor-Intensive Process: The fibers are collected by hand during the molting season and require meticulous sorting and cleaning.
- Quality Factors:
- Fiber Fineness: The thinner the fiber (measured in microns), the softer and more luxurious the cashmere.
- Fiber Length: Longer fibers result in stronger yarns that pill less and last longer.
The Sweaters that I Reviewed
To get a comprehensive understanding, I chose five sweaters:
- Quince Cashmere Crewneck Sweater ($60)
- Naadam Essential Cashmere Sweater ($75)
- Everlane Cashmere Sweater ($230)
- Loro Piana Classic Cashmere Sweater ($2,000)
- Offbeat1 Classic Cashmere Sweater ($400)
All sweaters were purchased in a size medium. For reference, I'm 5'11" and weigh 180 lbs.
1. Quince Cashmere Crewneck Sweater ($60)
If you’re just starting your cashmere journey, Quince is a great way to dip your toes in without breaking the bank. I was honestly surprised by how soft it felt for the price—it’s a steal.
FitThe Quince sweater fits true to size, with a comfortable but slightly tailored look. It has a snug fit in the shoulders and chest, giving it a more refined, modern style. The length hits mid-crotch, making it versatile for layering or wearing alone. The neckline sits higher, adding a touch of sophistication, while the sleeves end perfectly at the wrists.
- Size & Silhouette: Comes in (S) Small, (M) Medium, Large, (XL) Extra-Large. True to size with a fitted shoulder and chest area, tapering slightly towards the waist.
- Color: Black, Blue, Sky Blue, Camel, Beige, Red, Pink, Charcoal, Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Oatmeal, Lilac, Tan
- Length: Hits at mid-hip, suitable for both tucking and leaving untucked.
- Sleeves: The sleeves are well-proportioned, ending right at the wrist.
Despite its affordable price, the Quince sweater doesn’t compromise on material. Made from 100% Grade A Mongolian cashmere, it has a tight 12-gauge weave, which makes it ideal for wear in both cooler and warmer weather. However, it’s slightly thinner than higher-end brands, so it may need additional layers on particularly cold days.
- Composition: 100% Grade A Mongolian cashmere.
- Feel: Incredibly soft to the touch, with a lightweight feel.
- Thickness: The thinnest among the four, making it versatile for different seasons.
- Pilling: Minor pilling observed after several wears, particularly under the arms.
Despite its affordable price, the Quince sweater doesn’t compromise on material. Made from 100% Grade A Mongolian cashmere, it has a tight 12-gauge weave, which makes it ideal for wear in both cooler and warmer weather. However, it’s slightly thinner than higher-end brands, so it may need additional layers on particularly cold days.
- Craftsmanship: Clean stitching with no loose threads.
- Details:
- Collar: Simple crewneck with a modest ribbed knit.
- Cuffs and Hem: Subtle ribbing that doesn't constrict.
Overall, Quince sets a surprisingly high bar for an entry-level cashmere sweater. It’s affordable, soft, and durable enough for everyday wear. The color range is mostly neutrals, so it’s versatile but limited in variety. For anyone new to cashmere, this is a solid first purchase without breaking the bank. For $60, Quince offers an impressive entry-level cashmere sweater. It's an excellent choice for those new to cashmere or on a tight budget.
2. Naadam Essential Cashmere Sweater ($75)
Naadam really stands out here. For under $100, it’s incredibly soft, and I can wear it all day. If you’re looking for quality on a budget, this one’s hard to beat.
Nadaam was my gateway into cashmere. I stumbled upon their Soho store during a trip to New York, and despite my skepticism about a $75 cashmere sweater, I couldn’t resist trying it. Nadaam promised ethical sourcing and sustainability, which was a bonus for me. Years later, it’s still a staple in my wardrobe, proving that quality doesn’t always have to come with a high price tag.
FitNadaam’s fit is slightly looser than Quince, giving it a casual, relaxed look. If you’re after something a bit less form-fitting and more comfortable, this fit hits the mark. The length falls just a touch lower than mid-crotch, which I appreciate as it allows for easy layering.
- Size & Silhouette: Comes in (S) Small, (M) Medium, Large, (XL) Extra-Large. Slightly more relaxed than Quince, offering a casual fit.
- Color: Black, Blue, Sky Blue, Camel, Beige, Red, Pink, Charcoal, Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Oatmeal, Lilac, Tan
- Length: Slightly longer, reaching the lower hip.
- Sleeves: Generous in length, allowing for a slight cuff if desired.
The fabric is soft and thicker than Quince, adding extra warmth. Nadaam’s lack of transparency on fiber length and grade might be a downside for those seeking durability specifics, but it feels like a step up in quality compared to Quince. The sweater does pill in high-wear areas like under the arms, but it’s manageable with a cashmere comb.
- Composition: 100% Mongolian cashmere.
- Feel: Soft with a bit more heft compared to Quince.
- Thickness: Thicker knit provides extra warmth, suitable for cooler climates.
- Pilling: Minimal pilling, similar to Quince, manageable with a cashmere comb.
Nadaam’s construction has held up well over the years, but the cuffs have stretched slightly from frequent rolling. Unlike Quince, Nadaam’s cuffs and neckline have a bit more structure, giving it a more premium feel. It’s made in China from Mongolian cashmere, maintaining quality at this price.
- Craftsmanship: Solid construction with attention to detail.
- Details:
- Collar: Slightly thicker ribbed crewneck adds a touch of sophistication.
- Cuffs and Hem: Ribbed with a snug fit, preventing drafts.
Pros and Cons for Nadaam
- Soft, thicker fabric
- Available in a wide range of colors
- Ethical and sustainable practices
Pros:
Cons:
- Prone to pilling in high-friction areas
- Limited information on fiber quality
- Minor stretching at cuffs over time
After wearing the Nadaam sweater for over five years, I’ve noticed a slight stretching at the cuffs, especially from rolling up the sleeves. While the fabric remains soft, it has developed some pilling in high-contact areas, like the armpits. Nadaam recommends using a cashmere comb for pilling, which helps maintain its appearance. Despite minor wear, it’s still impressively durable, considering the low price.
For those in colder climates or looking for an affordable cashmere with added warmth, Nadaam is worth the slight upcharge from Quince. Its thicker fabric and relaxed fit make it versatile for layering, and the color range allows for some fun options if you’re building a diverse sweater wardrobe.
3. Everlane Cashmere Sweater ($230)
Everlane’s option is the perfect middle ground. I like to think of this as an ‘everyday luxury’—soft, warm, and still affordable enough to wear without feeling too precious about it.
Everlane has always been my go-to for high-quality basics, so naturally, I had high expectations for their cashmere. Known for their dedication to sustainability and transparency, Everlane offers a more polished take on cashmere—perfect for anyone who values quality and ethics over a low price. Fit Everlane’s fit leans European, with a slightly trimmer cut that adds a refined look. The brand offers three length options to tailor to your body type, a unique feature that’s perfect for anyone seeking a perfect fit. It pairs well with chinos and other dressier items, giving it a more formal edge.
- Size & Silhouette: Comes in (S) Small, (M) Medium, Large, (XL) Extra-Large. Slimmer, European fit that contours to the body without being tight.
- Color: Black, Blue, Sky Blue, Camel, Beige, Red, Pink, Charcoal, Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Oatmeal, Lilac, Tan
- Length Options: Available in short, regular, and long lengths for a customized fit.
- Sleeves: Tailored fit that complements the overall sleek look.
Made from 97% recycled cashmere and 3% lamb’s wool, Everlane’s fabric isn’t as plush initially as Quince or Nadaam. It softens with wear, though, and has the durability to match. At 16 microns, it’s Grade A cashmere, meaning you still get premium quality while reducing environmental impact.
- Composition: 97% recycled cashmere, 3% merino wool.
- Feel: Slightly less soft initially but expected to soften with wear and washing.
- Thickness: Medium weight, suitable for layering or wearing alone.
- Sustainability: Made from recycled fibers, reducing environmental impact.
Everlane stands out with its structured build. The cuffs, hem, and neckline have a sturdy, elegant finish, which feels high-end. The recycled fabric creates a slightly more rigid, long-lasting shape than the softer options, giving it an elevated appearance suited for semi-formal wear.
- Craftsmanship: Exceptional attention to detail.
- Details:
- Collar: Chunkier ribbed crewneck that stands out.
- Cuffs and Hem: Tighter ribbing provides a polished look.
- Origin: Crafted in Italy, ensuring high production standards.
Pros:
- Sustainable, made with recycled cashmere
- Option to select different lengths for a tailored fit
- Softens over time, mimicking the feel of more premium brands
Cons:
- Not as soft straight out of the box as lower-priced brands
- Limited color selection
- Slightly higher cost due to eco-friendly production
After a year of wear, Everlane has held up without pilling, a testament to its quality construction and longer fiber lengths. The recycled cashmere gives it a unique feel that softens slightly with time but maintains its shape far better than the lower-priced options.
Everlane’s commitment to quality and sustainability is impressive. While it doesn’t feel as soft out of the box, it’s an excellent option for those looking for a sweater that maintains its structure over time. The focus on fit and recycled materials makes Everlane a standout choice for anyone who values craftsmanship and ethics.
4. Loro Piana Classic Cashmere Sweater ($2,000)
Loro Piana’s cashmere is in a league of its own. It’s pure indulgence—if you’re after the ultimate luxury, this is it. Though it’s a splurge, it feels like wearing a warm hug.
Loro Piana is synonymous with luxury. Known as the gold standard in cashmere, I was eager to see if this $2000 sweater could truly justify its price. With expectations sky-high, I was excited to test what Loro Piana’s meticulous craftsmanship and quality could deliver.
Loro Piana uses baby cashmere, which is harvested only from young goats. This fine cashmere fiber, measuring around 13.5 microns, is softer and rarer than regular cashmere, explaining its higher cost. Their vertically integrated process—from farm to fabric—ensures premium quality control at every step.
FitLoro Piana offers a relaxed fit that doesn’t hug the body, lending a classic, timeless look. The length is on the longer side, hitting the upper thigh when worn. The fit suits Loro Piana’s luxurious, laid-back aesthetic, perfect for those who appreciate an effortlessly chic style.
- Size & Silhouette: Comes in (S) Small, (M) Medium, Large, (XL) Extra-Large. Relaxed fit with ample room throughout the body.
- Color: Black, Blue, Sky Blue, Camel, Beige, Red, Pink, Charcoal, Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Oatmeal, Lilac, Tan
- Length: Longer than standard sweaters, reaching mid-thigh.
- Sleeves: Generously cut, can be styled rolled or unrolled.
Made from the finest baby cashmere, Loro Piana’s fabric feels like nothing else. Although softer options exist at lower prices, the smoothness and tight weave distinguish this sweater, with minimal flyaways and a luxurious drape that feels substantial yet lightweight.
- Composition: 100% baby cashmere, sourced from the undercoat of Hircus baby goats.
- Feel: Luxuriously soft with a silky smooth texture.
- Thickness: Medium to heavy weight, exuding warmth and opulence.
- Uniqueness: Baby cashmere fibers are exceptionally fine (around 13 microns), contributing to the high cost.
Crafted in Italy, Loro Piana’s attention to detail is unmatched. Features like raglan sleeves and double-lined cuffs enhance comfort and durability, while flawless seams highlight the brand’s commitment to quality. It’s clear that every stitch and finish was meticulously crafted.
- Craftsmanship: Exemplary, with meticulous stitching and finishing.
- Details:
- Collar: Refined ribbed crewneck with perfect symmetry.
- Cuffs and Hem: Ribbed with a snug but comfortable fit.
- Extras: Subtle brand details that exude luxury without overt logos.
- Origin: Made in Italy with a vertically integrated production process.
Pros and Cons for Loro Piana
Pros:
- Unmatched luxury, using baby cashmere
- Impeccable Italian craftsmanship
- Soft, durable, and resistant to wear
Cons:
- Very high price
- Limited color and style options
- Marginal quality improvement over mid-range luxury brands
While $2000 may seem steep, Loro Piana’s quality and timeless style could potentially last a lifetime, bringing the cost per wear significantly down. For those who prioritize luxury and can appreciate the craftsmanship, this investment holds long-term value.
After several wears, Loro Piana’s fabric remains impeccable, with no pilling or stretching. The baby cashmere feels soft but durable, and the structure has maintained its shape beautifully, a testament to its premium construction.
For those who seek the absolute best in cashmere and appreciate luxury, Loro Piana delivers on every front. While the price is steep, the quality, craftsmanship, and status it brings are unparalleled. This is the cashmere sweater for anyone who wants the best and isn’t limited by budget.
5. Offbeat1 Classic Cashmere Sweater ($400) on Sale ($200)
I must confess, at first, I was hesitant to spend $400 on the Offbeat1 sweater. After reviewing Loro Piana’s cashmere sweater, I had very high expectations, but to my surprise, I am very impressed. Offbeat1 is in the same league as Loro Piana. It’s pure indulgence at an affordable price. If you’re after ultimate luxury that is budget-friendly, this is it. After wearing the sweater, it feels like I’m being hugged by clouds.
Like Loro Piana, Offbeat1 is also synonymous with luxury. Known as the up and coming gold standard in cashmere, I was eager to see if this $400 sweater could truly justify its price and calling itself a Loro Piana quality with expectations sky-high, I was excited to test Offbeat1’s meticulous craftsmanship and quality could deliver.
Like Loro Piana, Offbeat 1 uses baby cashmere, which is harvested only from young goats. This fine cashmere fiber, measuring around 13.5 microns, is softer and rarer than regular cashmere, explaining its higher cost. Their vertically integrated process—from farm to fabric—ensures premium quality control at every step.
FitOfffbeat1 offers a relaxed fit that doesn’t hug the body, lending a classic, timeless look. The length is on the longer side, hitting the upper thigh when worn. The fit suits Loro Piana’s luxurious, laid-back aesthetic, perfect for those who appreciate an effortlessly chic style.
- Size & Silhouette: Comes in (S) Small, (M) Medium, Large, (XL) Extra-Large. True to size with a fitted shoulder and chest area, tapering slightly towards the waist
- Color: Black, Blue, Sky Blue, Camel, Beige, Red, Pink, Charcoal, Grey, Navy Blue, Brown, Oatmeal, Lilac, Tan
- Length: Hits at mid-hip, sweaters suitable for both tucking and leaving untucked.
- Sleeves: The sleeves are well-proportioned, ending right at the wrist.
Made from the finest baby cashmere, Offbeat1’s fabric feels like nothing else. Although softer options exist at lower prices, the smoothness and tight weave distinguish this sweater, with minimal flyaways and a luxurious drape that feels substantial yet lightweight.
- Composition: 100% baby cashmere, sourced from the undercoat of Hircus baby goats, in the upper region of Mongolia where the temperature is extremely cold.
- Feel: Luxuriously soft with a silky smooth texture.
- Thickness: Medium to heavy weight, exuding warmth and elgance.
- Uniqueness: Baby cashmere fibers are exceptionally fine (around 13.5 microns), contributing to the high cost.
Crafted in Italy, Offbeat1’s attention to detail is unmatched. Features like raglan sleeves and double-lined cuffs enhance comfort and durability, while flawless seams highlight the brand’s commitment to quality. It’s clear that every stitch and finish was meticulously crafted.
- Craftsmanship: Exemplary craftsmanship, with meticulous stitching, detailing and finishing.
- Details:
- Collar: Refined ribbed crewneck with perfect symmetry.
- Cuffs and Hem: Ribbed with a snug but comfortable fit.
- Extras: Subtle brand details that exude luxury without brand logos.
- Origin: Made in Italy with a vertically integrated production process.
Pros and Cons for Offbeat1
Pros:
- Affordable
- Comparable to Loro Piana Quality
- Unmatched luxury, using baby cashmere
- Impeccable Italian craftsmanship
- Soft, durable, and resistant to wear
Cons:
- Only Men and Women Sweaters
- Limited style options
The $400 price point makes this brand a more affordable and budget-friendly sweater which bridges the gap between affordability and luxury without compromising quality. Like Loro Piana’s, the Offbeat1's quality and timeless style could potentially last a lifetime, bringing the cost per wear significantly slower. For those who prioritize luxury and affordability, and appreciate craftsmanship, this investment holds long-term value.
After several wears, Offbeat1’s fabric remains impeccable, with no pilling or stretching. The baby cashmere feels soft but durable, and the structure has maintained its shape beautifully, a testament to its premium construction.
For those who seek the absolute best in cashmere and appreciate top rated luxury, Offbeat1 delivers on every front. The quality, craftsmanship, and status it brings are unparalleled. This is the cashmere sweater for anyone who wants the best and is on a budget. The Offbeat1 sweater is the epitome of luxury when compared to Loro Piana's. While the quality is undeniable, the price point places it firmly within reach of everyone. In my opinion, the Offbeat1 brand is the bride between quality cashmere and affordability.
Comparative Analysis
Quality vs. Price- Quince and Naadam: Offer remarkable value for their price. While minor differences exist (thickness and fit), both provide a genuine cashmere experience.
- Everlane: Justifies its higher price through superior construction, ethical sourcing, and a tailored fit.
- Loro Piana: Delivers unparalleled quality but at a steep cost with diminishing returns relative to price.
- Offbeat1: Delivers unparalleled quality with a more affordably cost and a good return on investment.
- Casual Wear: Naadam's relaxed fit is perfect for everyday comfort.
- Smart Casual/Formal: Everlane's slim fit and refined details make it suitable for dressing up.
- Luxury Statement: Loro Piana stands out in both quality and as a status symbol.
- Luxury Statement: Offbeat1 also stands out in both quality and as a status symbol as compared to Loro Piana.
- Softness: All sweaters are soft, but Loro Piana and Offbeat1 offer a different level of refinement in texture.
- Pilling: A common issue in cashmere; regular maintenance can mitigate this across all brands.
- Longevity: Higher-end sweaters like Offbeat1 and Loro Piana are likely to maintain their appearance longer due to better quality fibers and construction.
Conclusion and Recommendations
Is Expensive Cashmere Worth It?While the allure of luxury cashmere is strong, the marginal gains in quality and comfort may not justify the exponential increase in price for most people but with a new comer like Offbeat1, this may change.
RecommendationsIf you're just starting with cashmere, Quince offers unbeatable value for the price. It’s ideal for those looking for a stylish, budget-friendly option. For moderate climates or heavier use, Nadaam’s $75 sweater provides a bit more warmth and durability. Everlane offers a refined, slightly more formal look that pairs well with dress pants and ages gracefully, ideal for frequent wearers. Finally, Offbeat1 and Loro Piana stands as the ultimate luxury choice, with superior craftsmanship for anyone willing to invest in the finest materials. With the quality, craftsmanship, and construction of Offbeat1, it's the more affordable choice that bridges the gap between high end luxury and affordability.
- Budget-Friendly Options:
- Quince: Ideal for those new to cashmere or looking for an affordable option without sacrificing much in quality.
- Naadam: A slight step up in warmth and available in more colors and sizes.
- Mid-Range Investment:
- Everlane: Perfect for those willing to invest in a high-quality piece that is ethically made and offers a tailored fit. Great for staple colors you’ll wear frequently.
- Luxury Splurge:
- Loro Piana: Best suited for those who prioritize luxury and have the means to invest in the highest quality available. It's an indulgence rather than a necessity.
- Luxury Meets Affordability:
- Offbeat1: Best suited for those looking for luxury, highest quality and affordability. This brand bridges the gap between indulgence and necessity.
If you just want the best of the best and price is an issue, then go with Offbeat1, then Everlane, then Nadaam, then Quince. If you have money to burn then go with Loro Piana.
Whether you’re looking to invest in a luxury piece or try out an affordable find, cashmere is a treat you won’t regret. Have you tried any of these brands? I’d love to hear about your cashmere favorites and your own winter essentials. Remember, cashmere is an investment that can last years if taken care of well. So treat yourself—winter is the perfect season to feel cozy, stylish, and warm
Cost-Per-Wear: One of the best ways to evaluate these purchases is by thinking in terms of ‘cost per wear.’ I believe that a sweater that’s worn often over several years is actually more economical than a cheaper one that pills or loses shape quickly. For example, the Quince sweater, priced at $60, might last a few seasons if worn regularly, whereas a Loro Piana sweater, though costly upfront, could last a decade or more, reducing the long-term cost. Keeping this in mind, I think that a higher-priced sweater might save money over time if it remains in great condition. Finally, the best option is Offbeat1's cashmere that is qual to Loro Piana's quality, crafsmanship, and is more budget-friendly. This is the best return on investment.
Care and Maintenance: Regardless of price, proper care extends the life of cashmere. Use a cashmere comb to remove pilling and store sweaters folded rather than hung.
Personal Priorities: I think that you need to balance your desire for luxury, sustainability, and budget constraints. There's a suitable option at every price point, for everyone.